Communication Strategy for the Preparation of Bulgaria for Membership in the European Union, January 15, 2002

 

The integration of Bulgaria in the European Union is a key priority in the programme of the government. At present, it enjoys the enormous support of Bulgarian society and full political consensus. According to a sociological study conducted in the autumn of 2001, 82 per cent of the Bulgarian citizens are in favour of the country's EU accession.

This is a favourable and encouraging fact, but the experience and the logic of earlier waves of EU enlargement indicate that the further away from membership a concrete country has been, the higher the support in society, and accordingly with the progress of the negotiations, this support decreased to a greater or lesser extent. The more real the accession became, the more tangibly the realities having both a positive and restrictive characters are experienced.

The task of the Communications Strategy is to put both on the scales in the public space and to give an opportunity to every social subject (institutional, group and individual) to become aware of the domination of the positive aspects of the process. The Communications Strategy is not a parallel process, but a dialogue with society and a way of guaranteeing its active position.

The analysis of the concrete situation in what has been done to popularise the European integration in society and to present Bulgaria abroad leads to the following principal conclusions and observations:

Strong points:

· The support for membership in Bulgarian society is very high.

· Governmental and non-governmental organisations have been working for a long time for the accession of the country to the EU.

· There exist qualified specialists who are engaged in these activities.

· There exists a well-developed system for mass communication.


· Information centres on matters related to the European integration are functioning and enjoy public prestige.

Weak points:


· The support for membership is rather abstract and the citizens do not perceive many of the real problems connected with the actual membership.


· The accession of the country to EU is still perceived more as a commitment and responsibility basically of the administration, whereas society remains aside from the process.


· There is insufficiently effective communication among the different institutions (governmental, non-governmental, EC Delegation and embassies of the Member States and candidates for membership).

 
· The messages of European integration are presented almost exclusively by political figures – the potential of the experts in the various fields is not sufficiently utilised (the working groups on the negotiations).


· The available communications network – the newsletters and the Internet sites of the different institutions – are not sufficiently effectively utilised. They offer too few opportunities for feedback from the citizens.


· The interests and the information needs of concrete groups in society are relatively little known.


· The viewpoint of the administration itself is directed basically to work with the institutions of EU and to the Member States and candidates for membership, whereas the communication with the citizens is rather insufficient.


· The public debate on European integration is too week and unilateral. It focuses on the candidacy of Bulgaria for EU membership, with total absence of the viewpoint on the future membership and the ensuing commitments of the country.

 
· Important topics for the European Union itself, of the type of the debate on the future of the EU, are not contemplated and discussed.


· Work with the different social groups, depending on their direct interests, is not sufficient and these groups are not sufficiently clearly identified.


· The communications channels are too centralised – work in the regions and locally is not sufficient.


· The information on the available projects and on the conditions for applying under them is relatively insufficient and ineffectively addressed, which is also one of the reasons for the poor absorption of these funds.


· The funds for such activities are insufficient.


· There is almost total lack of information materials in foreign languages on the candidacy of Bulgaria for EU membership.


· The work with the foreign media to attract their attention to Bulgaria as a topic is insufficient.


· There are relatively few events intended for popularising Bulgaria abroad.

 

These facts face us with the need of raising the issue about the communication on European integration on another principle. If until now it has been the main foreign policy goal, our present priority is to present it before society as a daily domestic policy issue, i.e., the messages of the European integration of Bulgaria need to be translated and addressed to the citizens in a comprehensible language and in the context of their real, daily dimension regarding the individual citizen.

With the advancing and acceleration of the course of Bulgaria's negotiations for EU membership, this topic is becoming the focus of public interest. This Strategy should mobilise and coordinate the existing institutions and resources for conducting a public dialogue for European integration, so as to meet the need of information, to prevent the disappointment after excessive and unrealistic expectations, to prepare society in advance for the need of applying concrete unpopular measures by linking them with the long-term goals of the country. All this would solicit real support for the governmental policy aimed at membership of the country in EU.

The implementation of such a type of communications policy would not only meet the need of information about what EU membership means for every citizen, but it would also lend democratic legitimacy to the process itself.

The EU enlargement should involve the entire society, not only the state administration. This means that it would be of utmost importance to start a debate simultaneously on the benefits and risks of membership, so as to meet the concerns of every citizen, which would inevitably arise with the increase in the public awareness of society.

Vision – the Bulgarian and the international communities actively support Bulgaria's membership in the EU.

1.       GOAL


The implementation of the Communications Strategy is aimed at bringing the Bulgarian citizens closer to the everyday dimension of EU membership, while at the same time targeted efforts are needed for increasing the knowledge of European citizens about Bulgaria. This also determines the thematic division of the entire campaign into two main lines, depending on the goals and on the public to which it is directed:

NATIONAL plan – directed inwards to Bulgarian society with the aim of explaining and bringing the Bulgarian citizens closer to the “European idea” of Bulgaria.
INTERNATIONAL plan - directed to the citizens of the 15 EU Member States, as well as to the nationals of the countries from the first wave of the enlargement, with a view to increasing the supporters of Bulgaria's candidacy for EU membership.

The EU institutions themselves are conducting a campaign on a large scale among the citizens of the Member States for raising the support for EU enlargement, which means that Bulgaria can use some of these communications channels.

The significance of such a popularising campaign is tremendous for the actual course of the negotiations, for attracting foreign investors, as well as for improving the overall image of Bulgaria.

Specific aims


On a national plan, the Communications Strategy pursues the following aims:
· To explain what the EU is;


· To explain what the benefits of membership are;


· To explain in advance what changes would occur upon acquiring full membership;


· To disseminate objective information about the EU and about its Member States in Bulgaria;


· To explain the results of the accession of Bulgaria to the EU, both for society as a whole and for concrete groups in it;


· To explain the connection between the pace of the preparation for membership and the process of negotiations;


· To motivate the more active participation of the Bulgarians in the process of integration and in the debate on the future of Europe;


· To explain the decisions of the state institutions, connected with the process of accession, and thus to guarantee their support;


· To prepare all professional circles in Bulgaria for successful integration in the EU policies from the very start of Bulgaria's accession;


· To clarify the price which Bulgaria would pay if it fails to join the EU, or if its accession is delayed;


· To improve the public knowledge and understanding of the pre-accession programmes of the EU and to motivate all partners for a more active participation in the processes of programming, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the pre-accession instruments of the EU.

On an international plan, the Communications Strategy has the following aims:


· To win the support and the positive attitude of the broadest possible layers of society in the Member States and candidates for EU membership;

 
· To assist the negotiations for accession through a campaign informing about the progress and creating a favourable climate for the completion of the negotiations;


· To disseminate and find supporters for the Bulgarian position in the debate on the future of Europe;


· To contribute to the successful ratification of the agreement for Bulgaria's accession to the EU by lobbying in the circles participating in the decision-making process in the Member States, in the circles forming the public opinion in Europe and in the EU institutions.
The methods, the intensity and the content of the popularising initiatives should be differentiated in the different EU countries depending on:


а) the degree of support for the idea of EU enlargement in the different member states;
b) the political, economic and social consequences for the respective states;
c) the role of a certain country in the EU.

2.      CHARACTER


From the very beginning after the identification of the need of such a strategy, its general outlook and partners, it is necessary to identify its character as well. The Strategy should be:

Decentralised – the information and the communication should try to cover as much as possible of the country's territory, especially bearing in mind that at present is it basically concentrated in Sofia and envisages more intensive coordination at regional, district and local levels.
Flexible – the actual process of negotiations is very dynamic, as well as the movement of public opinion, hence the Strategy should be in a position to respond to changes and to include new messages. This means that the Strategy and the immediate Action Plan need to be updated every year.

Involving dialogue – since this is a governmental strategy, it should be in a position to coordinate and unite the efforts of all institutions that are currently already making efforts to popularise and explain the European integration. In other words, it is of prime importance for the implementation of the Strategy to build a network of key figures and institutions actually participating in it.

3.      MEASURES FOR ATTAINING THE AIMS


In order to make such a type of political message acceptable to the broad public, it should be presented in a suitable, understandable and accessible form. They define the following main elements of the campaign:


1. Mobilising of available resources


· the press offices of the respective institutions;


· appointing a person to be responsible for the
Communications Strategy in the working groups on the different chapters of the negotiations with the EU.


2. Use of planned and implemented initiatives of other organisations and institutions
· Joint events with the EC Delegation or with non-governmental organisations;


· Expert meetings on the different chapters of the negotiations.


3. Training of the working team


4. Work with the target groups


· At national level


Persons with a high prestige (opinion leaders) are representatives of differently constituted groups, sufficiently numerous or sufficiently significant to society, so that their involvement with the EU cause to be of importance for the success of the campaign in the group whose representatives they are.

These are:


teachers and university lecturers;


officials in the state administration;


leaders of major organisations and parties;


journalists;
representatives of all religions;


university students;
representatives of business.
Motivated as co-participants in the campaign, they can assist in raising the general level of knowledge about the EU over a relatively short period of time.
Large social communities
The campaign should highlight a concrete positive aspect of the accession or to focus attention on the prevention or elimination of any apprehensions connected with the European integration of Bulgaria, which unites large social
groups:
professional,
age‚
political,
ethnic,
religious,
social.


These groups are also the first targets to which the campaign is to be directed. These are the groups in which a specialised interest in information about the EU has been identified.


· At international level


Participants in the process of negotiations:


High-ranking politicians;


Close advisers to these politicians;


Representatives of advisory institutions;


Political parties.


Circles shaping the public opinion in the Member States, notably:


Journalists;
Teachers and university lecturers;


Research institutes and political foundations;


Churches (in some countries);


Representatives of the embassies of the Member States and of the missions of international organisations in Bulgaria;


Leaders of public organisations (political, professional, business associations, regional), pressure groups and expert groups.


Broad circles of society in the Member States


The influence of third parties on decision-making in the EU, as well as on the formation of the position of the individual Member States, should not be underestimated. On this basis, the campaign should have a fourth target as well: the circles shaping public opinion outside the EU (other states of strategic importance and influential international organisations).
5. Partners
It is of enormous significance for this Strategy to be conducted in close cooperation with the non-governmental organisations and social partners in the country.

Another key partner in the implementation of the Strategy should be the EC Delegation in Bulgaria and the embassies of the EU Member States and of the aspirant countries in Bulgaria. All of them need to develop goal-oriented activities for raising the public awareness of the Bulgarian citizens on the issues of EU membership and the governmental programme in this sphere should take into account and complement what has already been done and planned by them in this respect. These institutions have experience, expert knowledge and resources for conducting such a campaign in Bulgarian society.

Of particular importance is also the coordination with the presidential institution, with the Committee on European integration of the National Assembly and with the Council on European Integration with the Council of Ministers on the implementation of the Strategy.

6. Communications techniques


At present there are many institutions and organisations, which use many of the techniques for dissemination of information to the citizens in Bulgaria and in the EU Member States for raising their knowledge and interest in the theme. The aim of the present Strategy is to coordinate and institutionalise the connection between them, so as to enhance the efficacy of each of the activities undertaken.


At national level


· Information centres on European problems (including those aimed at concrete EU programmes);


· Publications on the European theme (books, brochures, newspapers, magazines and journals, bulletins and newsletters, Internet);


· Radio and television broadcasts;


· Meetings and discussions with representatives of target groups.

At international level


· Events at the level of official institutions and non-governmental organisations at national and regional levels;


· Special events dedicated to Bulgaria;


· Advertising materials about Bulgaria;


· Establishing information centres in Bulgaria.

4.      IMPLEMENTATION OF THE AIMS SET

· Financing
The implementation of the Strategy will be financed with funds from the national budget for each concrete year jointly with the PHARE Programme. It is also necessary to establish special funds raised from the private sector for promoting Bulgaria abroad, which would secure a part of the financial resources needed for the campaign in the EU Member States.

For this purpose, funds should be allocated every year from the national budget for the implementation of this Strategy. It is necessary to activate the available resource provided by the European Commission from the PHARE budget for a Multi-Country Information and Communication Programme, controlled by the EC Delegation in Sofia. The aim of this programme is to assist the efforts of the national administrations of the candidate countries, whereby the EC Delegation is to provide the financing for joint projects and research.
It is necessary to seek financing from the EU Member States individually and from other potential donors.

· Organisational structure


It is necessary to create a general structure – Council on European Communications – under the auspices of the Chief Negotiator, whose main responsibilities are to be strategic planning and permanent monitoring of the implementation, with the obligation to undertake the necessary measures in the event of a change in the current situation (mostly on the basis of regular reports of the main participants in the Strategy and of the results of sociological surveys). Two subgroups are built within the frameworks of this unified structure:

At national level – in its capacity of chief coordinating body, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs forms a working group consisting of representatives of the principal institutions and organisations, which are to implement the Strategy. This group is to meet regularly every month. For the purpose, a special unit needs to be established at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to deal with the coordination of the campaign conducted. This structure is to take shape within the frameworks of the European Integration Directorate and is to consist initially of four persons in the European Secretariat and Coordination Department.

It is necessary to build a network of contact persons and institutions responsible for the implementation of the Strategy in the respective institution. These persons are to be responsible for the rhythmic and accurate supply of information by the respective institution or organisation about the policy pursued on European integration issues. They will be authorised to answer questions of the media and to assist them in obtaining information. Such persons need to be identified by each press centre, as well as by the working groups on the separate chapters in the negotiations with EU. They need to be in constant contact and cooperation with the coordinating unit at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and to participate in the working group;

At international level - the Ministry of Foreign Affairs is the chief coordinator through the established unit in the European Integration Directorate, whereby the actual implementation of the Strategy is to be done on the spot in the respective Member States through the Bulgarian missions and embassies abroad. Each of them is to propose a concrete Action Plan in the countries, depending on the concrete specificities of these countries and taking into account the general priorities of the Strategy for presenting and popularising the image of Bulgaria abroad.

Both principal elements of the Strategy are to be implemented through direct and permanent connection with all state and private institutions, which participate and are interested in the attaining of this goal.


The campaign is to be conducted also in close cooperation with the EC Delegation and with the embassies of the EU Member States in Sofia, with the aim of mutual complementarity and assistance.

· Stages
Each of the stages of the campaign needs to be directly linked to the implementation of the National Strategy for Bulgaria's accession to the EU, as well as to the development of the debate on the future of Europe. In this way, society will receive timely information - ahead of time, if necessary - about the process of Bulgaria's adaptation to the EU requirements, about the reforms implemented by the government with a view to meeting these requirements, as well as in a more general plan about the essence and meaning of a structures like the EU.

The first stage of the campaign coincides with the period of intensive negotiations for membership; therefore its main goal should be to bring the citizens closer to the measures undertaken by the government in this direction. It is necessary to prepare society in advance for the actions undertaken, some of which are not popular. The focus should be on the long-term positive effect of these measures for the living standards of the individual citizen. It is very important at this stage to send messages before the occurrence of a concrete event in order to prepare public opinion.

The first stage should end in 2003, together with the completion of the accession negotiations of the country.

The second stage should focus on generating positive public attitudes to the future membership and involvement of a broad circle of society in the debate on the future of Europe and on Bulgaria's role in it.

The final date is connected with the real accession of Bulgaria as a full member of EU in 2006.

The third stage aims at explaining the rights and obligations stemming from our full membership. It is necessary to keep up the interest of the public in the theme, as well as to combine and intensify the messages from the first two phases.

With a view to drafting a concrete Action Plan until 2006, an assignment will be given to each state and private institution to give a description of its activities for the respective year and then on the basis of the generalisation and systematisation of the entire information to plan priority activities for every calendar year. This plan will take into account the national priorities for the respective year and in the different sectors (depending on the chapters in the negotiations that are to be opened or closed, the short-term reforms that need to be introduced and imminent unpopular measures). The concrete plan will be drafted with deadlines and commitments of the concrete institutions and organisations, which will be responsible for its implementation.


The annual updating of this document is assigned to the coordinating institution - the Ministry of Foreign Affairs - with the assistance and cooperation of all participants from the governmental and non-governmental sectors.

5. MONITORING AND EVALUATION

The need to establish such a practice stems both from the fact that it should serve as the basis for shaping the image of the campaign‚ and in view of the need for it to be updated already in the course of its implementation. The effectiveness of the Strategy introduced can be checked precisely with such regular studies both within the frameworks of society as a whole‚ and among its individual parts. It is necessary to use also the results of similar studies in the different Member States on the attitudes to the Bulgarian candidacy with the help of our missions abroad (Eurobarometer). The image of the campaign and the changes in its line should be determined in accordance with the results of these studies.

Such studies should be assigned regularly as a part of the obligations of the coordinating institution and their results should be used for updating the priorities of the Strategy for a concrete period of time.